Malkovich stuns in Wild Horse Nine, a tense, contemplative and irreverent musing on guilt, mortality and Arkansas.
Finally, after what felt like decades of seeing this film’s trailer in theaters, “Wild Horse Nine” has been released into the world for all to enjoy, including me and hopefully you as well. It was written and directed by Martin McDonagh, starred John Malkovich, Sam Rockwell, Steve Buscemi, Mariana di Girolamo and Parker Posey and will be lightly spoiled by me in this review.
First off, my viewing experience with “Wild Horse Nine” was complicated, because while I believe it is both well-made and enjoyable, there was a jarring tonal whiplash between what I expected and what I received. It took a minute to settle into the film, but once I acclimated, I was sat. The trailers market it as a comedy with thriller elements; something vibrant and stylized, like a Quentin Tarantino film. I believe it would be far more accurate to describe “Wild Horse Nine” as primarily a drama. At its core, it is about reckoning with one’s regrets, coming to terms with mortality and recognizing that complacency is defeat.
We follow Chris (Malkovich) and Lee (Rockwell), two Central Intelligence Agency agents taking a brief vacation to Easter Island after engineering the 1973 Chilean coup d’etat. For those of us who are not history majors, the 1973 coup was a military-led usurpation of the newly democratically elected socialist government of Chile. In real life, while there is no explicit proof that the CIA was directly involved, the United States was hugely supportive of the socialist government’s collapse and indirectly created the conditions that led to the coup. The takeover led to a torrent of human rights abuses within Chile as the new government began a long and brutal campaign of political suppression through torture, exile and execution.
On a slightly lighter note, the movie is gorgeous, having been filmed on location and using the scenic vistas of Easter Island to its aesthetic advantage. We are treated to many shots of the moai heads and the rocky grasslands, which is something I think the trailer advertised quite well. As to the more man-made aspects, the film is very ‘70s, so if you like that kind of orange-brown, retro-modernistic style, then you will appreciate the care and thought they put into the set dressing and wardrobe.
During their time on Easter Island, Chris and Lee are left to contemplate their choices in life and the effect they have had on the world. Their long-standing trust in each other begins to erode as long-buried things come to light. Though, like I said, I would not describe “Wild Horse Nine” as a thriller, it does have quite a great deal of underlying tension that ratchets up as the film nears its climax. The pacing is mostly smooth and calculated, giving its bigger and heavier moments time to breathe without dragging on (although I did think the first 20 minutes were a bit slow going). I am being vague on the details, purposefully, because the gradually drip-fed mystery is engrossing and it would be a shame to deprive you of that.
As for the performances, there has been a lot of buzz for Malkovich to get an Oscar off of this movie and I can see why. He always excels at dry comedy, and this entire film is a chance for him to listlessly monologue and make dry quips about absurd observations, and it somehow works. You never know how lucid his character is at any moment, but that is the point: it does not matter. To Chris, nothing matters anymore, and Malkovich sells this so well. It is incredibly intriguing to wonder what could bring a man firmly entrenched in the weeds of political espionage to such a bleak point.
It might be easy to disappear in the shadow of such a strong performance, but Rockwell more than holds his own. Lee is basically playing the “straight man,” just trying to keep everything from falling apart while mediating between his partner, Chris and his boss, MJ (Buscemi), and it provides a solid balance to Chris’ erratic behavior. Beyond this, his character has so much emotional depth, and Rockwell’s face reflects it all so well. His facial expressions provide equal amounts comedy and character work. He is constantly shifting between figurative masks based on the situation, and the tiniest of facial expressions let little glimpses of his true feelings peek through. This is best displayed during his phone calls with his wife, Marge (Posey). It is a caricature of a dysfunctional mid-70s marriage, absurd to comedic extreme, but also complicated by so many little details and inflections that communicate how much they care for each other deep down. This authenticity is crucial to making the audience care, and the movie excels at creating relationships that feel old and well-worn.
Those relationship dynamics are also the primary source of comedy in “Wild Horse Nine.” The film has plenty of jokes, mostly from Malkovich’s character, but they are purposefully at odds with the film’s tone. They are always underscored by another, bleaker emotion. The irreverent humor of the film acts as a painkiller, making the tough subject matter easier to take-in without dragging the mood down too far. I think McDonagh wanted to avoid becoming too dour and defeatist, because for all its melancholia, “Wild Horse Nine” ends with a flicker of hope. It is interesting, but Chris’s carefree and relentless sardonicism serves the same purpose within the film as it does to the audience. As Chris, along with the viewer, reflects upon the weight of his past deeds and confronts his mortality, he uses humor to soften the reality of it all, and so we are eased into it as well. There are several scenes where Chris discusses something truly upsetting with such a causal tone of voice that it almost makes you forget how horrible it is; you begin to question how much humanity he still has left.
This brings me to the aspect of “Wild Horse Nine” that I love the most: its meta-commentary on the U.S. and its legacy. Our main characters, especially Chris, are microcosms of America as a whole. This country, just like Chris, has done terrible things, sometimes for good reasons, but mostly for morally dubious or outright bad ones. As the country grows older, we must come to terms with that, choose to confront it or else let it kill us. “Wild Horse Nine” absolves no one of their guilt, but it does let them grow to make better choices and push others to make better choices than they did. This latter element is most deeply represented by Monica (di Girolamo), a Chilean college student whom Chris befriends.
All this to say, if you intend to see “Wild Horse Nine,” which I highly encourage, please adjust your expectations accordingly and put the trailers out of your mind. To quote Marty McFly, “This is heavy.” It’s a thought-provoking commentary on regret, mortality and the banality of evil.
★★★★⯪
“Wild Horse Nine” receives 4.5/5 stars from this reviewer.